Today Kerry James Marshall: Mastry opened at the Met Breuer. Situated among the extended art history of an encyclopedic museum filled with so-called old masters, Mastry's installation in New York will reveal Kerry James Marshall's works' deep connection to the past. We asked our Associate Director of Education: Public Programs and Interpretive Practices, Rosie May, to reflect on Marshall's references to art history in his works.
on Renaissance masters
I’ve spent much of my career as an art historian absorbed in the Italian Renaissance surrounded by the works of masters like Masaccio, Donatello, Michelangelo, and Caravaggio. While preparing for the Mastry exhibition, I was struck by the similarities between Kerry James Marshall and his Renaissance forerunners. They are all driven by a desire to bring stories to life by creating recognizable figures in relatable settings. They have also diligently studied and honored their debt to their predecessors but brought a contemporary spin to their work.
Renaissance artists worked throughout their careers to represent Christian saints and scenes from the Bible with realistic human figures. Creating convincing, three-dimensional figures was a skill that had been lost after the fall of the Roman Empire so Renaissance artists turned to ancient Greek and Roman sculpture. They often made trips to Rome to learn how to create lifelike human forms by studying the remains of ancient sculpture.
on reflecting on the past
They focused not only on the forms of the bodies but also on the poses that their predecessors used to animate the works. Yet Renaissance artists added new elements: human emotions and contemporary settings. For example, Masaccio set the biblical scenes in his frescoes in the streets of Northern Italy and dressed his figures in contemporary clothing. Similarly, Michelangelo represented the biblical hero David preparing to go into battle with Goliath by giving him the body of an ancient Greek or Roman sculpture of a god, but added a human reaction—an expression of anticipation and determination with a penetrating gaze and a furrowed brow. Caravaggio took the advances even further by taking people off the street and having them pose as models for biblical figures. He painted them with their lined and tired faces and dirty hands and feet demonstrating that holy figures looked just like everyone else.
Walking through Marshall’s exhibition, I could see echoes of the Renaissance artists in his work and, like these old masters, he produced paintings that paid homage to his predecessors but created new meanings.
on Adam and Eve in art history
In Vignette (2003), he drew on Massaccio’s Expulsion of Adam and Eve from the Garden of Eden from the Brancacci Chapel in Florence. It was one of the first frescoes to depict both a naturalistic representation of the human body and an outpouring of emotion, showing Eve weeping into her hands as she and Adam are banished from Eden. Scenes of Adam and Eve were extremely popular in painting and sculpture during the Renaissance. Marshall’s Vignette is composed like one of these Renaissance depictions of Adam and Eve with a nude man and woman surrounded by foliage, tress, butterflies, and birds. But his figures are strong and black and his “Adam” wears a necklace in the shape of the African continent, perhaps suggesting the location of the Garden of Eden. For Marshall, introducing these elements into the classical theme asserts the importance of these figures in the story of humankind.
on sampling from the past
Much like the Renaissance artists would adopt the poses of ancient sculpture to demonstrate their knowledge of their predecessors, Marshall’s Portrait of Nat Turner with the Head of His Master (2011) borrows the contrapposto pose of Donatello’s sculpture of the biblical hero David after he had slain the giant Goliath. While Donatello’s work is famous for being the first life-size, free-standing nude since the ancient Roman period, Marshall was likely equating Nat Turner to the young boy David who, against all odds and expectations, saved his people, the Israelites, from the menacing Philistine army led by the giant Goliath. In this way, Marshall reclaims Nat Turner as a civil rights hero and a saint who musters the courage to face his menacing and brutal white master.
In this painting, Marshall also draws on a later generation of Renaissance artists like Caravaggio and Artemisia Gentileschi who created more dramatic and explicit scenes in their work. Caravaggio painted several works depicting David triumphantly holding the bloodied head of Goliath; and Gentileschi made paintings of the biblical heroine Judith who saved the Jewish people from the threatening Assyrian army by seducing and beheading the general Holofernes. Marshall took the gory realism of these paintings, with their severed heads and bloodied axes, to revisit the brutal reality of Turner’s deed but also to recast him as a biblical hero.